120 – Is Islam True? Questioning Ex-Muslim Abdullah Sameer @Friendly Exmuslim
In this episode, I joined @MythVisionPodcast on his channel to take calls from Muslim callers. This was a very lively and respectful discussion and we explored different topics. Some of the topics include Free will VS determinism, Pagan and Christian influences on Islam, as well as the topic of Apostasy and apostasy laws.
On the topic of Apostasy, we explored the origins of the law, the various hadith, and interpretations from respected scholars. We also took calls from two Muslims who approach this topic differently but both reach the conclusion that apostasy laws are not fundamentally a part of Islam. Also, we discussed the story of Jesus’s crucifixion both from a Christian and Islamic perspective.
@MythVisionPodcast and I then took a call from Miran who wanted to discuss the problem of not having a single authority in Sunni Islam when it comes to issues of Islamic fiqh, hadith authentication, and scholarly advice. The conversation then, later on, moved to the topic of historical Muhammad and the story of Aisha.
I hope you will enjoy this episode.
YouTube version of this podcast: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcPSLHTgpBM
Timestamps:
0:00 Introductions
6:22 Islamic apologetic’s reliance on the free will argument. Surah 10.
17:37 The Perfect Dawah – There is no predestination in Islam. Is Isis the true interpretation of Islam?
29:28 Comments from the live chat
30:34 Victor – Shoutout
31:27 Cush – Crucifixion of Jesus
35:15 Abdullah Sameer’s take on the crucifixion of Jesus according to Islamic teachings.
38:46 The Pagan influences in Islam
40:27 Crucifixion of Jews by the Romans 20 years before Jesus.
41:41 Whysthetruth –
43:41 Pagan influences in Islam
47:40 Superchat
48:05 Apostate Prophet – Sheik Yabooty
57:55 How do Muslims know there was an uncorrupted holy book?
1:00:16 Advice for Muslims who want to leave Islam but are married to Muslims.
1:02:14 The influences of Pre-Islamic Arabia on Islam.
1:03:16 Rashid – Compliments for Abdullah
1:04:50 Nader – The Quran’s position on Apostasy. Surah 4: 137
1:25:23 Superchats – How is it possible that Pharoh was able to speak perfect Words
1:27:10 Muhammad was a dictator who wanted total submission.
1:31:10 Comments from the super chats
1:32:56 What is the ruling on the apostate?
1:39:55 Muhammad was a fascist political leader whose actions created a fascist political-religious ideology.
1:42:02 Rashid – Complements and introductions
1:45:17 Hadith give the impression that it is okay for apostasy.
1:48:49 Why Rashid is Muslim
1:50:16 Super chat – Other prophet claimants other than Muhammadin the 7th-century
1:52:54 Was the idea of Muhammad being the final prophet a way to prevent political uprisings after his death?
1:59:40 Muhammad might have been a Christian before Islam – Christian influences on Islam.
2:03:30 Miran – Is the lack of a single authority in Sunni Islam problematic?
2:13:23 Historical Muhammad and the story of Aisha.
2:19:50 Super chats
2:22:42 Final remarks and channel announcements.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download