086 – Interview with Exmuslim Amina from Denmark
Amina Sardar is a former Muslim who started doubting Islam after the Mohammed Drawing Crisis in Denmark and this lead to her investigation of Muhammad and her eventual apostasy Had a great healthy discussion about immigration, radicalization, Hizbut Tahrir, Moderate Muslims, Muslims in Canada vs. Denmark, Islamophobia, Victim Narrative, Discriminating against Muslims, and more. Enjoy!
Her YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_Mg7qWwR5dWI3groLtttwg
YouTube version of this interview: https://youtu.be/PZnjLmaoXrM
Here are the time stamps for the interview:
0:00 Introductions.
1:00 Amina’s upbringing – growing up with an ultra-conservative father.
4:36 Why is it Amina’s parents treated her differently from her brothers?
6:15 Amina’s family background/roots.
7:50 Amina’s arranged marriage. The excessive control that fathers have over their daughters’ marriages
13:44 The incident of prophet Muhammad’s cartoons in Denmark.
15:57 Learning about Muhammad’s marriage to Aisha and how Amina reacted to this news.
21:11 Taking a deep dive into Islamic teachings and seeking the truth. Joining politics and how the Muslim community started harassing Amina and her family.
26:03 Leaving Islam and coming out.
28:25 Reading comments from the chat.
29:14 Continuation of Amina’s coming out story.
32:33 Why Amina thinks there are no moderate Muslims.
36:20 Why is it Muslims never take time to ask ex-Muslims why they left Islam instead of shunning them?
39:27 The cost of leaving Islam.
41:20 Using an open mind and outsider perspective to study Islam.
43:11 Is there any form of democracy in Islam? The problem of Islamic platforms being insular.
48:18 Is Denmark a Christian country or a secular country? What does moderate Muslim mean?
52:00 We should support Muslims who are trying to secularize Islam. The fighting between moderate Muslims and extremist Muslims.
59:03 Some sections of the Muslim community using democracy and the democratic system to push their religion. Using Islamaphobia to push a victim mentality in the Muslim community.
1:11:10 Abdullah’s response to the issue of Taqqiya. Muslims getting into western politics and participating in the democratic process. Discrimination and victim mentality
1:54:20 Danish people’s response to the immigration situation. The ISIS brides and deradicalization process.
2:22:10 Final remarks and link to Amina’s channel.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Hello,
I am a Muslim by birth however I have been to trying to know Islam and doing some research work to know what is real Islam. Amina Sardar in some video has said that she found a contradiction in the Quran so I want to know those contradictions and also interact with her on the other issues related to Islam. Can I have her WhatsApp or email id. Thanks
No sorry I dont give out personal info. You can try to contact her on FB or IG
What she is saying about killing Shias is correct. I heard it in Saudi Arabia. This is a reflection of deep rooted hatred of Wahabis against Shias.